top of page
  • Writer's pictureAdmin

SCC adopts CDAS submissions in R. v. Barton

Daniel Song and Matthew Nathanson (photographed below) recently represented CDAS in the Supreme Court of Canada in R. v. Barton, 2019 SCC 33, a precedent-setting case dealing with myriad important issues. Barton addressed a number of issues related to sex assault prosecutions, such as when applications are required in order to lead evidence of prior sexual history under s. 276 of the Code. However, Barton’s significance extends well beyond the sexual assault context. On behalf of CDAS, Mr. Song and Mr. Nathanson argued that the Crown should not be permitted to take inconsistent positions at trial and on appeal, raise new issues, or advance new theories of liability. This argument was based on fundamental notions of fairness and the double jeopardy rule. We are pleased to advise CDAS’ members that these arguments were accepted by the Supreme Court of Canada. This decision will be helpful in situations where the Crown seeks to shift away from the position it advanced at trial in order to gain a tactical (and potentially substantive) advantage on appeal. While such Crown behaviour will likely be rare, Barton provides significant ammunition against it when the need arises. Mr. Song and Mr. Nathanson are pleased to have successfully advanced CDAS’ position. This achievement will hopefully be one of a series of successful interventions at the Supreme Court of Canada that solidify CDAS as a significant force in the advancement of the criminal law.

109 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

CDAS Addresses Parliamentary Committee

On March 27, 2023, CDAS addressed the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights at a hearing focused on Canada's Bail System. This Committee was formed in response to the recent let

CDAS Bids Farewell to Mark Gervin

CDAS co-founder and long-time Vice-President, MarkGervin, has decided to step down from the Board of Directors. Forever an altruist, Mark explained that his goal was always to see CDAS establish itsel

New CDAS President: Gloria Ng

CDAS is proud to announce that Gloria Ng has been appointed as the new President of the Society. Ms. Ng has been a Director of CDAS since 2015. She runs a successful criminal defence practice, Platfor

bottom of page